From my post yesterday, it certainly seems that there are people who want to discuss class at Wiscon, altho’ we all kind of agreed that previous attempts have largely failed. Two things that, to me, seemed to keep recurring in the comment thread:
- a “class 101″ discussion is in order to sort of establish a baseline. It seems like we can’t really get to deeper discussions of class because we’re all still looking for entrance points to discuss class: what is it, why should we discuss it, how do we discuss it?
- a relatively firm structure is in order to keep the discussion moving forward. Suggestions ranged from having a firm structure evident in the panel/round-table description to having a skilled, strong moderator. Actually, i think the necessity of a strong moderator is what recurred most. Anyone want to be a moderator?
The 1st title suggestion that pops into my head (and it’s late, so possibly i’m talking out of my ass) is something like “Marxism & beyond: Assembling a class discussion toolkit.” I dunno, i kind of want to acknowledge that Marx’s ideas are important, but aren’t the end of discussing class. And it sure feels like we need a toolkit.
Personally, i kind of envision such a discussion happening in one of the smaller rooms — because it’s easier to hear and easier to be heard without shouting, and also i dislike the idea of panelists being up on a dais for a discussion of class. :p Thoughts on whether people might prefer having a panel-led discussion, or maybe having a round-table?
had what i thought was a good idea for how to summarize this discussion on the programming form:
“talking about class at wiscon is hard. where should we start? what can we say? sometimes this discussion goes horribly wrong– how can we avoid it?”
Does that work for people? Modifications to suggest?
- – -
ETA: Almost forgot! From that comment thread, 2 other suggestions on potential avenues to enter a discussion of class: (1) A panel led by Brits. (2) Offering “what class am i?” stickers for all discussion participants — panelists and audience members alike. I’m not entirely sold on either of these ideas, but am happy to solicit more thoughts.
- – -
Finally: I’m probably going to keep talking about this shit between now and … well, doomsday. So feel free to hold the panel here (or over on my blog — i’m not sure yet where i’ll be posting about this), ’cause pre-discussion before Wiscon certainly couldn’t hurt, and besides not everyone can make it to the convention anyway, y’know?
- – -
This was originally posted @ my LiveJournal.